Rupp Insurance
40 Executive Dr. # C
Carmel, IN 46032

Fax: 317-848-9854


Home, Auto & Business Insurance in Carmel, IN

Since our doors opened in 1973, Rupp Insurance has worked to provide high-quality commercial and personal insurance coverage solutions in Carmel, Fishers, Westfield, Noblesville, Zionsville, Indianapolis, and surrounding areas in the state of Indiana. With 50 years of collective experience, our staff of dedicated, hardworking agents is knowledgeable about the insurance industry, and we strive to be the best in the business.

At Rupp Insurance, our community is important to us. We want to get to know the clients we serve, and we are active in the area we live and work. Additionally, we are proud supporters of local organizations such as OneZone and the Westfield Chamber of Commerce.

Travel, Home, Flood, Commercial Insurance & More

From personal policies such as home insurance and auto insurance, to tailored commercial coverage, Rupp Insurance has everything you need to be your one-stop shop for coverage.

We can write personal policies ranging from high end home insurance to flood insurance, and we customize commercial coverage plans such as contractors insurance, commercial property insurance, and vacant dwelling. We offer coverage options for a wide range of businesses, and specialize in working with manufacturers, dentists, and restaurants.

Our staff of forward-thinking and experienced agents works directly with our clients to ensure the best policy gets put in place. Once our clients are matched with the right coverage, we then turn to trusted carriers such as Nationwide, Progressive, and others.

Please contact us at your convenience for additional information about our products and services.

Friendly Agents Serving You

The process of purchasing insurance is not always a walk in the park. At Rupp Insurance, we understand that, and our goal is to make the overall experience as convenient as possible for our clients. We pride ourselves on quality customer service, and our agents are accessible for anything our clients might need.

Once we have put the best policy in place for a client, we review coverage prior to renewal on an annual basis. If any changes or tweaks to coverage need to be made, we’re happy to make those happen.

Please request a quote to begin working with one of our agents.

Additional Resources

Indiana Department of Insurance (IDOI))

Insurance Buyer’s Guides (The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC))

Small Business Insurance Details and Resources (The U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA))











Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required



Meet Our Team

R.J. Rupp
R.J. Rupp


Jeanira Sebastian
Jeanira Sebastian



Rupp Insurance handled a 'total' of my car and from the time I called them at the accident site til the settlement, they held my hand and acted swiftly and proactively. I have never waited longer than 5 minutes for a call back and they are genuine and compassionate. I recommend them without reservation and appreciate this kind of personalized customer service. Thanks, Team Rupp !

David V.

We have been using them for years for our Business! Love Jill and RJ! You won't get more personalized and friendly service! They are on top of everything they do!

Jeff J.

We use R.J Rupp for all of our insurance needs since 2004 and we are happy with the services.

Valerian S.

Contact Us